You folks all bring up some great points. Most of this discussion is quite accurate. Jay even got it right! Those Custom-3’s must be doing their job.
There are several things to consider for LRC designs. Here are some rules:
1. Most dialog comes from the center channel. That is where the image on the screen is so the speech comes from there. (It is also easy for a lazy audio engineer to keep all the dialog in the center mix … but that issue should be for a separate discussion)
2. Left and Right are usually vertical arrays and centers are horizontal thus the directivity and phase summation off axis is inverted. This is the first problem.
3. The big screen takes up a lot of space (hopefully) so in most homes that are 8 feet in room height there is less vertical space for a center speaker.
4. Wives don’t want to see speakers. Some of you guys are luckier than others but this is the norm. No offense to you ladies, in your defense as men we can’t even dress properly, so how could we think about room design unless we were… ahhhh….more feminine.
5. A lighter mass will accelerate quicker than a heavy mass. So with the same BL (magnet strength) a 6” speaker will have better HF response, and attack.
6. You need as much if not more Center Channel Speaker output capacity compared to L/R due to the inherent application of soundtracks.
It would be great to have three symmetrical speaker solutions for LCR but ergonomics don’t easily allow for this. The Sound Broker has the right approach if you can consider a perforated screen with speakers behind it like at the pro theaters. (The exception would be the AMC Theaters which has Dr. Eugene Patronis’s EV solution above the screen).
So what is the alternative? More smaller diameter speakers and more voice coils.
Trust me… The RC-64 does NOT have any problems keeping up with the RF-83 as long as you use a subwoofer, but a RC-84 would be a great option and make sense. Why didn’t we do it? I think there were too many complaints about limitations in the vertical dimension to use a same size driver design from our dealers.