KG-4 vs. Heresy III - The Klipsch Community
in
Advanced Search
KLIPSCH - The Ultimate Sound Experience

KG-4 vs. Heresy III

Last post 04-02-2010 5:22 PM by opteron44. 6 replies.
Page 1 of 1 (7 items)
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  • 03-30-2010 5:11 PM

    KG-4 vs. Heresy III

    I have found another option to upgrade and wanted to know any opinions. Since I use the system mostly for 2 channel music, I am posting here.

    Here is my system: Sony WEGA 32FS13, Rotel CD855 CD Player, Oppo BDP-80 Blu-Ray / DVD Player, NAD T-163 pre/pro, Front /Center Amp: Emotiva XPA-3, Rear Amp: Emotiva UPA-2, Front Speakers: Klipsch KG-4 (1986), Rear Speakers: Acculine A-1 (2009), Center Speaker: Emotiva ERM-1(2009), Sub: Dali S 1.2 (2008)

    I am thinking of getting Heresy III's for up front and using one of the KG-4's as a center channel (and selling the Emotiva center channel) for HT use.

    1. Will the Dali sub provide whatever I lose in the bass response by making this change?

    2. Can I place the Heresy's in roughly the same place as the KG-4's and get the same full soundstage that allows flexibility in seating along the opposite wall (not a small sweet spot)?

    3. Any reasons this is a good or bad idea?

    Thanks very much for all thoughts.

    Emotiva UMC -1 Pre/Pro
    Grant Fidelity B-283
    Rotel CD855
    Oppo BDP-80 Blu-ray / DVD
    Emotiva XPA-3 (fronts and center amp)
    Klipsch KG-4 (fronts)
    Klipsch SC-1 (center)
    Emotiva UPA-2 (rear amp)
    Acculine A-1 bookshelf (rears)
    Dali S12 Subwoofer (crossover at 60 MHz)
    Panasonic TCP50ST30
  • 03-30-2010 9:09 PM In reply to

    Re: KG-4 vs. Heresy III

    Heresy IIIs have much improved bass response vs. HIs.

    Not familiar with your sub, but I do not even use my sub for 2 channel....

    And I have Heresy Is.

     

    I think you will be blown away by the mid and upper frequencies of the HIIIs (3 way vs. 2 way; updated design).

    And they do thump nicely......

     

    My .02

     

    Good Luck.

    DaniisGod

    Harman Kardon AVR 7300 Receiver
    Mains: 1980 Heresy HWO (Recapped with Sonicaps from Crites)
    Center: Klipsch KV4
    Surrounds: Klipsch SS-3s
    Sub: Emotiva Ultra 12

    KG Squared speakers and KG3s in extended family.... Music sounds great when visiting now!

    Sharp 52 " Aquos LCD TV

    PS3 Fat 120GB

    All In a dedicated living room!
    (And with my Woman Who APPROVES IT!!!)

    Klipsch KG Squared Speakers and Harman Kardon HK 430 Twin Powered Receiver.

    Klipsch RF 52s and RC 35 (Thanks Cliff!!!), Kenwood SHT32 Sub in the Bedroom with an HK AVR 500 mated to a PC and 40" Sony Bravia LCD
    Promedia 2.1 satellites as surrounds (for now)
    Woo Hoo!
  • 03-30-2010 11:27 PM In reply to

    Re: KG-4 vs. Heresy III

     Both are similar in size but thats about it, the 3 way Heresy III will provide much better overall sound and more realism. I would say it would be a bad match between the two.

    KG4's are nice sounding in their own right but seem less efficient and kinda bass heavy sound, you can always give it a try and see what you think but you may want to match up your speakers for the best overall sound.

    Never heard the Dali sub either so no comment there, sorry.

    LaScala's with Tuba HT
    Chorus II

    Fed by Radio Shack's finest audio cables.
  • 03-30-2010 11:50 PM In reply to

    Re: KG-4 vs. Heresy III

    The HIII's are fabulous speakers. I'd suggest to move them around to see what positioning yields the most pleasing sound.

    Don't know about using the KG4 as a center. It would be worth doing a comparison with the emotiva to see what offers the clearest voice and such.

    molon labe
  • 03-31-2010 5:12 PM In reply to

    Re: KG-4 vs. Heresy III

    Thanks for your thoughts, gentlemen.

    I am encouraged by everything I am reading about the H III's and think that they will be a meaningful step up for me. Given the size of my room (9 x 18 x 7.5), I think that they are probably as large as I can go with the Heritage line.

    From what I have seen here, it would appear fair to think that if the Emotiva amp does a great job with the KG-4, I should be happy with what it does with the H III's.

    Unfortunately, I have to wait for my strained elbow to heal before I can order them - right now, I couldn't get them up the steps into the listening room!

    Emotiva UMC -1 Pre/Pro
    Grant Fidelity B-283
    Rotel CD855
    Oppo BDP-80 Blu-ray / DVD
    Emotiva XPA-3 (fronts and center amp)
    Klipsch KG-4 (fronts)
    Klipsch SC-1 (center)
    Emotiva UPA-2 (rear amp)
    Acculine A-1 bookshelf (rears)
    Dali S12 Subwoofer (crossover at 60 MHz)
    Panasonic TCP50ST30
  • 03-31-2010 5:30 PM In reply to

    Re: KG-4 vs. Heresy III

    You could have them shipped to me, and I will send them to you when your elbow heals!

    Surprise

     

    Seriously..... hope you get better soon.....

    Post pics when you get them...... Yes

    We like pics....

    DaniisGod

    Harman Kardon AVR 7300 Receiver
    Mains: 1980 Heresy HWO (Recapped with Sonicaps from Crites)
    Center: Klipsch KV4
    Surrounds: Klipsch SS-3s
    Sub: Emotiva Ultra 12

    KG Squared speakers and KG3s in extended family.... Music sounds great when visiting now!

    Sharp 52 " Aquos LCD TV

    PS3 Fat 120GB

    All In a dedicated living room!
    (And with my Woman Who APPROVES IT!!!)

    Klipsch KG Squared Speakers and Harman Kardon HK 430 Twin Powered Receiver.

    Klipsch RF 52s and RC 35 (Thanks Cliff!!!), Kenwood SHT32 Sub in the Bedroom with an HK AVR 500 mated to a PC and 40" Sony Bravia LCD
    Promedia 2.1 satellites as surrounds (for now)
    Woo Hoo!
  • 04-02-2010 5:22 PM In reply to

    Re: KG-4 vs. Heresy III

    Pretty funny!

    Thaks for the good wishes: when I get them in, I will post my review.

    Emotiva UMC -1 Pre/Pro
    Grant Fidelity B-283
    Rotel CD855
    Oppo BDP-80 Blu-ray / DVD
    Emotiva XPA-3 (fronts and center amp)
    Klipsch KG-4 (fronts)
    Klipsch SC-1 (center)
    Emotiva UPA-2 (rear amp)
    Acculine A-1 bookshelf (rears)
    Dali S12 Subwoofer (crossover at 60 MHz)
    Panasonic TCP50ST30
Page 1 of 1 (7 items)
©2009 Klipsch Audio Technologies. All rights reserved.