DeanG

  I am on a quest to make my system as ear freindly as possible. With the Musical Fidelity I belive it will give me the best of both world smooth sound on music and good sounding movies, however I may need some network upgrades for  the Forte II as well as my Academy ( with new KLF C7 drivers due to thermal meltdown by my teenage boys). Colerphoto1 and Popbumber ran test at Klipsch to find suitable replacements since Klipsch does not make Academy drivers any longer. The KLF drivers had a little forward presentation that will work fine with movies however Michael said it was a little much on 5 channel music and maybe we would have to build a new network.

mdeneen:

Really fine 2CH and really exciting movie listening are incompatible as far as using the same gear. Something has to give. 

Pardon me if this sounds like I'm missing something obvious, but if a system reproduces music accurately, wouldn't it also reproduce movie soundtracks just as accurately?  There are some folks who crank up the sub when watching movies, but I'm not one of them.  I assume that if the system is dialed in properly, it will make the movie sound the way the director intended.  Am I mistaken?

"I am on a quest to make my system as ear freindly as possible..."

Man, whacha doing messing with horns? :-)

I just remembered that Arcam always gets rave reviews for both music and HT.  I would check them out before you commit to the MF.

Islander:

mdeneen:

Really fine 2CH and really exciting movie listening are incompatible as far as using the same gear. Something has to give. 

Pardon me if this sounds like I'm missing something obvious, but if a system reproduces music accurately, wouldn't it also reproduce movie soundtracks just as accurately?  There are some folks who crank up the sub when watching movies, but I'm not one of them.  I assume that if the system is dialed in properly, it will make the movie sound the way the director intended.  Am I mistaken?

 

Which multichannel amps or surround processors have you found that sound "really fine" on 2 channel music?

We're just tossing our personal opinions here, right? Guys ask questions, opinions get offered, no?

So mine was, that I have heard a lot of cool movie sytems with realistic gunshots, howitzers, screaming car tires and whatnot, and I have certainly heard a lot of really fine and exquisite 2channel systems, and I have noticed that they never use the same equipment for both.  

DeanG:

. If you're into hair trigger transients and wide bandwidth -- tubes don't sound "musical".

 

 

thassa ..Thwack ..!!  Factor ..

My impression of the VRD's was that they had plenty of thwack.  I didn't notice any less than with my Crown.

frankphess:

           Long story short...if you want musical, put those Fortes on some tubes. Switching from one "mid-fi" solid state amplifier to another "mid-fi" solid state amplifier using the same solid state processor isn't going to make that much of a difference IMO. It may result in a "different" sound, but I doubt it will get more "musical.

           I have top of the line B&K seperates for 5.1 movies and a 2 channel tube system for music with RF-7's. I recently tried a Musical Fidelity A5 integrated with the RF-7's. I would rate tube system #1, B&K #2, Musical Fidelity #3. Now the A5 is an integrated, so while it is no slouch, it is certainly at a disadvantage being compared to separates, and I felt it was a liitle forward with Klipsch. While my B&K system is "impressive" in some folks eyes, it doesn't come close to a JM Peach and VRD amplifier musically.

           Another option might be to try a tube pre amp with a solid state amplifier, I think that would make more of an improvement than switching SS amps in and out unless of course you go big dollar SS.

 

 

As always new caps in the Fortes will help.

 

 

I agree with everything bolded.

 

Substitute BB for Peach

Substiute Sherwood Newcastle for B&K 

DeanG:

That word means different things to different people. If you're into hair trigger transients and wide bandwidth -- tubes don't sound "musical".

 

 

Why not make the statment complete by adding "LPs" to it? LMAO 

Islander:

mdeneen:

Really fine 2CH and really exciting movie listening are incompatible as far as using the same gear. Something has to give. 

Pardon me if this sounds like I'm missing something obvious, but if a system reproduces music accurately, wouldn't it also reproduce movie soundtracks just as accurately?  There are some folks who crank up the sub when watching movies, but I'm not one of them.  I assume that if the system is dialed in properly, it will make the movie sound the way the director intended.  Am I mistaken?

Agreed. I have listened to an amazing all tube/horn system that both music and movies were out of this world! The key is to have everything calibrated correctly and the room to be treated acoustically.

lakedmb:

The key is to have ... the room ...treated acoustically.

I don't believe that MF or Arcam is going to sound much different from your B&K. Tubes will sound different. However, if you want your system to sound better overall, SS or tubes, working on your room acoustics will give you the biggest return for your efforts.

 -Phil

mdeneen:

Islander:

mdeneen:

Really fine 2CH and really exciting movie listening are incompatible as far as using the same gear. Something has to give. 

Pardon me if this sounds like I'm missing something obvious, but if a system reproduces music accurately, wouldn't it also reproduce movie soundtracks just as accurately?  There are some folks who crank up the sub when watching movies, but I'm not one of them.  I assume that if the system is dialed in properly, it will make the movie sound the way the director intended.  Am I mistaken?

 

Which multichannel amps or surround processors have you found that sound "really fine" on 2 channel music?

I'm using stereo power amps for the main speakers and no processing (other than the EQing provided by the Dx38) for 2-channel music listening, since music is my first priority.  When watching a movie, I cut in the AV receiver's power amp to drive the center and surround speakers and run the receiver in 'Straight' mode, with no processing, since DTS or Dolby Digital come in with 5.1 channels sounding right that way and the movies sound sufficiently exciting for my needs.

Perhaps my electronics are not up to some of the high-end stuff you're familiar with, but adding the surround channels for movies doesn't compromise the 2-channel music listening, at least with my setup.  Multi-channel is becoming more important anyway, with all the concert DVDs, some of which have excellent sound that has a depth you can't get with 2 channels, due in part to the higher res of the DVDs relative to CDs.

When the budget permits, I may get a multi-channel pre-pro and a 3-channel amp for the surround channels, but as I mentioned, 2-channel music sounds great and 5.1 movies are pretty good too, until the day when I upgrade by getting three more JubScalas, but I'm in no rush to do that.

BTW, Mark, have you thought of using a Dx38 as a crossover with a pair of your amps to power Jubilees or JubScalas?  That could sound really fine.

Why not make the statment complete by adding "LPs" to it? LMAO 

Are we now going to now pretend that all LP's sound better than all CD's? I've heard a lot of really bad sounding records in my time.

Hey they also make a very musical watch as well

http://www.musicalfidelity.com/merchandise/watches/25thwatch.html